First-born.
Earns more.

Sociological Science  /  2026

Decades of research say the eldest child gets more schooling and better pay. A new US study asks the obvious next question, and the answer is a paradox.

An older sister walks down a country road with her arm around her little brother, seen from behind, in black and whitePhoto: Unsplash
First-born / earns more
Later-born / earns less
First-born / no happier
Later-born / just as happy
Feature · Family · Kithmark
By Sarah McCord Jamwal
/01

The short answer

A new study of about 15,000 Americans, including about 7,000 siblings, finds that first-borns keep their money and career edge but are no happier than their younger brothers and sisters. The study's best lead on why points somewhere money can't reach: how each child was parented.

/02

The eldest-child advantage is real.

If you're the oldest, the research has mostly been on your side. A landmark 2005 study of Norwegian registry data found that first-borns get more education, and that each later child does a little worse. Economist Kjell Salvanes, one of its authors, says the pattern holds no matter how big the family is, for schooling, earnings and the chance of full-time work.

1st
2nd
3rd
4th–5th
−1 year Children born fourth or fifth average about one year less schooling than the first child. (Norway) Only the first and last steps are measured. The middle steps are drawn to show the slope.
0%

The premium first-borns earned in their first job, in a 2016 study of men across eleven European countries.

Why? Researchers point to time and attention. First-borns spend their early years with no sibling to share their parents with. In April 2026, a new international study added another piece: younger siblings are much more likely to be hospitalized with serious breathing illness as babies, which may explain about half the gap between first and second children.

/03

They aren't happier.

Earnings

First-born
Later-born

Life satisfaction

First-born
Later-born

Across the population, first-borns' family income was about $6,000 a year higher. Life satisfaction, mood and mental health: no significant difference. Bar lengths show direction, not scale.

Money and status usually go with higher life satisfaction. Theories of happiness predict first-borns should be happier. They aren't.

The new study, published in Sociological Science by Tamkinat Rauf of the University of Wisconsin–Madison, measured both sides, money and well-being, in the same people. It used two nationally representative US surveys that follow people over many years. Across the population, the result held up: first-borns had higher incomes, about $6,000 a year more in family income, and showed no significant edge in life satisfaction, mood or mental health. Their mood and mental health came out lower than their income would predict. That gap is the paradox.

Some earlier studies even found first-borns had worse psychological well-being. This study's headline is more careful: no advantage at all.

/04

So what's eating the eldest?

Family dutiesYou might guess eldest children carry more responsibility, and the load cancels out their gains. The data didn't support that.
Money matters lessFirst-borns didn't seem to get less happiness out of each extra dollar.
Harsher parentingThe one lead the study found. Abuse by parents in the teen years seemed to be one pathway lowering first-borns' mood and mental health as adults. Accounting for it shrank the gap but didn't close it, so the author calls it one possible factor, not the whole answer.

Anyone who grew up in a big family can fill in the blanks: the eldest who was the test case for every rule, who got the strictest curfew, who heard "you should know better" and "set an example." The youngest who got away with more. Those differences don't show up on a paycheck. They may show up decades later in how settled a person feels.

/05

What this means at your table.

Success isn't ease.

The sibling who "did best" on paper may not feel it. Ask before you assume.

Same parents, different parents.

Each child grew up with a different version of Mom and Dad. Siblings argue about the past because they lived different ones.

Old roles stick.

The eldest still organizes. The youngest still gets teased. Notice the old script, and choose a different line.

How Kithmark helps

Find out how much your siblings really know you.

Kithmark is for the relationships that are close, complicated and hard to talk about. Keep a private record of how things are going with each parent and sibling, and spot the patterns you keep repeating. Before the holiday, practice a hard talk with "Bringing up money" or "A boundary with a parent or in-law." At the table, play "Who knows me" or "Family quiz."

Kithmark Free in the iPhone beta.
Android coming soon.
Sources
Birth-order paradox, ASA 2026 program
Rauf, "The Happiness Paradox of Birth Order," Sociological Science, 2026
NHH, "Being born last can come at a cost," April 28, 2026
Bertoni and Brunello, Demography, 2016
By Sarah McCord Jamwal
Co-founder and CEO, The Wired Ape
Share
The Inheritance Issue

Kithmark › Family · 4 min read

First-borns earn more. They aren’t happier.

First-borns earn more. They aren’t happier.

First-borns earn more. They aren’t happier.

Decades of research say the eldest child gets more schooling and better pay. A new US study asks the obvious next question, and the answer is a paradox.

Decades of research say the eldest child gets more schooling and better pay. A new US study asks the obvious next question, and the answer is a paradox.

Decades of research say the eldest child gets more schooling and better pay. A new US study asks the obvious next question, and the answer is a paradox.

Sarah McCord Jamwal

SHARE

TagsFamilySiblingsBirth orderSociology
Share this article

Sources

About the author

TRY THE APP

Kithmark betaTry Kithmark free on iPhoneScan with your iPhone camera to join the beta on TestFlight, Apple’s app for testing new apps. Free in the beta. Android coming soon.Join on TestFlight

THE CLEARING DISPATCH

One email. All of The Wired Ape.

New stories on family, ritual, the brain and belonging, plus news on Kithmark and Ritual OS. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Practitioner? Your letter lives on The Firekeepers page →

More from this issue

More from this issue

More from this issue