The Clearing · Issue 03 · DispatchLoss and Remembrance · Ritual OS

Gallery 05 · On loan from deep time

Half a million years of keepsakes

A ticket stub, a shell from a beach, your grandmother's ring. New research suggests the habit of keeping objects that hold memories may be about 500,000 years old, and may have helped build the human memory itself.

By Sarah McCord Jamwal

Obj. 01 · Colorful pebbles
Qesem Cave, Israel
c. 400,000–200,000 yrs ago

The short answer

Researchers at Tel Aviv University propose that early humans kept objects with no practical use, such as colorful pebbles, fossil-marked hand axes and old tools, as keepsakes. Over many generations, they argue, those objects may have shaped the parts of the brain that let us remember our own lives. It's a hypothesis, not proof, and the authors say so.

A hand in a plaid sleeve holds out one small, smooth stonePhoto: Unsplash
Keepsake · any human · any age

The pebbles nobody needed

In Qesem Cave in Israel, archaeologists found small, round, colorful pebbles. They weren't tools. Nobody found any practical use for them. Yet early humans carried them into the cave again and again over roughly 200,000 years, starting about 400,000 years ago.

They aren't alone. At other sites in Israel, people made hand axes shaped around an embedded fossil or an unusual swirl in the stone. At Revadim, a site about 500,000 years old, people picked up flint tools that earlier humans had made, used and thrown away, tools that had grown a crust of age, and reworked them. Ran Barkai, one of the archaeologists, has argued that they did it because they valued things made by those who came before.

Deep time · scale: one line = half a million years

0

years ago · Revadim

0

years of carrying pebbles · Qesem

500,000400,000300,000200,000100,000today Qesem Cave: pebbles carried in, again and again Revadim: old tools picked up and reworked your drawer 500k400k300k200k100ktoday Revadim: old tools reworked Qesem Cave: pebblescarried in, again and again your drawer

The idea

A memory you can hold

The new paper, published in the journal Evolutionary Anthropology, was led by Dr. Yoav Ram of Tel Aviv University's School of Zoology and Professor Ran Barkai of its Department of Archaeology, with Professor Liad Mudrik, Dr. Ella Assaf, Dr. Bar Efrati and independent researcher Tal Simon.

They combine archaeology with psychology, neuroscience and evolutionary theory to make a simple proposal:

i

Early humans brought home objects that marked a place they'd been or something that happened to them.

ii

Those objects worked like an external memory device, a prompt to remember a specific moment.

iii

Keepsakes may also have helped with a hard mental job: telling a real memory from an imagined one.

iv

Over many generations, that may have increased evolutionary pressure on the brain systems that track where a memory came from and how reliable it is.

In short, our habit of keeping things may have helped make us the kind of animal that remembers its own life, and builds a sense of self from it.

The big animals go · new ground to learn · new things to remember

Barkai links the timing to a changing world. As elephants and other large animals disappeared, early humans had to learn new hunting grounds and new ways of living, and objects that held memories of places may have mattered more.

Hypothesis

Curator's note

Read it as a hypothesis

The authors are careful, and so should we be. Nobody can interview a person from 400,000 years ago about why they kept a pebble. The paper proposes an idea and suggests ways to test it, such as comparing possible keepsakes with ordinary tools for wear and origin, or testing whether people who keep meaningful objects are better at telling where their memories came from.

☐ keepsake vs. tool: wear and origin

☐ do keepers know where memories came from?

What's not in doubt is the pattern: for a very long time, humans have picked things up for reasons that have nothing to do with use.

Why we still do it

Think about what's in your drawer. A wedding invitation. A child's first shoe. A note in a handwriting that no longer arrives. You don't keep them because you'll use them. You keep them because holding them brings someone back.

That's the oldest job of a keepsake, and it's why remembrance rituals across the world so often begin with an object: a photograph set on a table, a candle, a favorite cup, a piece of clothing.

photograph · candle · favorite cup · a piece of clothing

our wedding invite

first shoe

Call me when you get in. Love, Ma

a handwriting that no longer arrives

0 minutes

Try this

Pick one object that holds a person or a moment for you.

This week, give it five minutes. Hold it. Say out loud, or write down, the memory it carries. Then put it somewhere you'll see it.

Ritual OS practice screen, Meetbreath: breathe in for four, hold gently for two, breathe out slowly for eight

How Ritual OS helps

Ritual OS is full of practices built around objects that carry meaning. Every practice shows the items it uses before you begin: the traditional item first, then everyday stand-ins. Often the thing you already keep is exactly the right one. Each step is guided, so the moment gets the attention it deserves.

Scan to join

Ritual OS is free in the iPhone beta.

Sources EurekAlert! release, Tel Aviv University, "Were humans collecting keepsakes as early as half a million years ago?" · i24NEWS on the study's authors and evidence · StudyFinds on the Qesem Cave pebbles and the journal details · The Brighter Side of News on the Sakhnin Valley hand axes and how the idea could be tested · Canadian Friends of Tel Aviv University on recycled tools at Revadim

Share
The Inheritance Issue

Ritual OS › Loss and Remembrance · 5 min read

Half a million years of keepsakes

Half a million years of keepsakes

Half a million years of keepsakes

A ticket stub, a shell, your grandmother’s ring. New research suggests the habit of keeping objects that hold memories may be about 500,000 years old.

A ticket stub, a shell, your grandmother’s ring. New research suggests the habit of keeping objects that hold memories may be about 500,000 years old.

A ticket stub, a shell, your grandmother’s ring. New research suggests the habit of keeping objects that hold memories may be about 500,000 years old.

Sarah McCord Jamwal

SHARE

TagsRemembranceArchaeologyMemoryRitual
Share this article

Sources

About the author

TRY THE APP

Ritual OS betaTry Ritual OS free on iPhoneScan with your iPhone camera to join the beta on TestFlight, Apple’s app for testing new apps. Free in the beta. Android coming soon.Join on TestFlight

THE CLEARING DISPATCH

One email. All of The Wired Ape.

New stories on family, ritual, the brain and belonging, plus news on Kithmark and Ritual OS. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Practitioner? Your letter lives on The Firekeepers page →

More from this issue

More from this issue

More from this issue