A bearded man in profile against a pale background, looking away, in black and whitePhoto: Unsplash

Kithmark feature · Boundaries

When
they
go

Two families can hit the same rough patch. One stays in touch; the other goes silent. A new study asks whether personality helps explain the difference, and its answer is more about fit than fault.

By Sarah McCord Jamwal · Co-founder and CEO, The Wired Ape

In a 2026 study of 520 Americans in strained parent-child relationships, parents who scored higher on enthusiasm were more likely to have been cut off by an adult child. Adult children who scored higher on openness were less likely to have cut off a parent. The authors call the findings preliminary, and they don't say anyone is to blame.

How common is it?

Estrangement between parents and grown children isn't rare. Researchers estimate it touches somewhere between 6% and 28% of people at some point in their lives. In one national US study, 26% of adult children reported a period of estrangement from their father, and 6% from their mother.

People who go through it often describe it as a "clash of personalities." Until now, nobody had tested that idea with numbers, according to the authors of the new study.

The study

"From strain to estrangement: the role of personality in predicting parent-child relational outcomes" was published in Frontiers in Psychology in 2026, by Jag S. Gill of Adler University, independent researcher Matthias J. Barker and Carl P. Nienhuis of the University of the Fraser Valley.

They invited about 2,000 members of an online support community for parent-child estrangement. 582 answered, and 520 US residents made the final sample: 368 parents, average age 60, and 152 adult children, average age 39, from different families. Everyone had a strained relationship. "Estranged" meant seeing and speaking once a year or less. By that measure, 48% of the parents and 35% of the adult children were estranged. Everyone took a 100-item test of the Big Five personality traits.

SAME STRAIN STAYS IN CONTACT more open adult children ENDS IN ESTRANGEMENT more enthusiastic parents

What they found about parents

Warmth,
too much

Only one of the five broad traits mattered: extraversion. Parents who scored higher had higher odds of having been cut off by an adult child.

The detail is what makes it interesting. In this study, enthusiasm, meaning warmth, expressiveness and wanting lots of contact, carried the link. Assertiveness, the more forceful side, didn't. So the authors don't read this as controlling parents driving children away. They suggest a mismatch: a parent who wants frequent, emotional, high-energy contact may overwhelm a grown child already struggling in the relationship.

Agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism and openness showed no link for parents. Neither did divorce.

The same warmth that feels loving to one person can feel like pressure to another.

Parent's extraversion

+79% odds of being cut off

Parent's enthusiasm

+57% odds of being cut off

Adult child's openness

−78% odds of cutting off

Adult child's curiosity about ideas

−60% odds of cutting off

Adult child's openness to emotions and other views

−57% odds of cutting off

Change in the odds of estrangement for each one-point rise in the trait. Source: Gill, Barker and Nienhuis, Frontiers in Psychology, 2026

What they found about adult children

A more
open mind

For adult children, the trait that mattered was openness to experience. Those who scored higher had much lower odds of having cut off a parent.

Two parts of openness carried that: curiosity about ideas, and openness to emotions and other points of view. A more flexible mind may help someone live with a parent's different values, or let a slight go, without ending contact. Adult children with a master's degree or doctorate also had lower odds of estrangement in one of the models.

A woman in soft side light, face turned to the window, in black and whitePhoto: Unsplash

Read this with care

It can't show cause

One snapshot. A painful break could change how people see their own personality.

It's one support group

Mostly White women. People in support groups may differ from those who handle distance quietly.

Small groups, many tests

Only 53 adult children were estranged. Several results barely passed. The authors call it preliminary.

Different families

Parents and children weren't matched, so how their traits interact is unknown.

Personality isn't a verdict. Many estrangements follow real harm, and stepping back can be the healthiest choice someone makes. What this study adds is a way to see why two families with the same kind of strain can end up in such different places.

A bigger shift

The study sits inside a wider change. A 2025 study of estranged Americans described a newer way many younger people think about family, sometimes called "democratized kinship." In that view, family ties aren't owed no matter what. They depend on mutual respect, accountability, real effort to connect, and emotional safety.

A 2015 study found something similar: differences in personal values predicted estrangement between mothers and adult children far more than a child breaking serious social rules.

Put together, the research suggests many cutoffs aren't about one dramatic event. They come from a long mismatch in what each side needs: how much contact, what kind, and on whose terms.

What you can do with this

If you're the parent: ask how your grown child wants to stay in touch, and how often. Less, and on their terms, can keep a door open that more would close.

If you're the adult child: name what you need before you reach the end of your rope. "A call on Sundays works for me; daily texts don't" is a boundary, not a rejection.

If you've already stepped back: that can be the right decision. Our guide to stepping back from family safely walks through how.

How Kithmark helps

For the relationships
that are hard

Kithmark keeps a private record, encrypted on your phone, where you can track how contact with a parent or child actually feels over time, not just how often it happens. Rehearse a hard talk first with the practice topic "A boundary with a parent or in-law." And Kithkeepers, family therapists, coaches and mediators, are joining, for when you want a trained person in the room.

Free in the iPhone beta.
Android coming soon.
Sources: PsyPost, "In strained families, extraverted parents are more likely to be cut off by their adult children," Nov 6, 2026 · Gill, Barker and Nienhuis, Frontiers in Psychology, 2026 · Read next: Stepping back from family, when and how to do it safely Share
The Inheritance Issue

Kithmark › Boundaries · 5 min read

When grown children cut ties

When grown children cut ties

When grown children cut ties

Two families can hit the same rough patch. One stays in touch; the other goes silent. A new study asks whether personality helps explain the difference.

Two families can hit the same rough patch. One stays in touch; the other goes silent. A new study asks whether personality helps explain the difference.

Two families can hit the same rough patch. One stays in touch; the other goes silent. A new study asks whether personality helps explain the difference.

Sarah McCord Jamwal

SHARE

TagsFamilyEstrangementPersonalityPsychology
Share this article

Sources

About the author

TRY THE APP

Kithmark betaTry Kithmark free on iPhoneScan with your iPhone camera to join the beta on TestFlight, Apple’s app for testing new apps. Free in the beta. Android coming soon.Join on TestFlight

THE CLEARING DISPATCH

One email. All of The Wired Ape.

New stories on family, ritual, the brain and belonging, plus news on Kithmark and Ritual OS. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Practitioner? Your letter lives on The Firekeepers page →

More from this issue

More from this issue

More from this issue